Reclaiming Influence: Beyond the Superficial Social Media Stereotype
Reclaiming the Term 'Influencer': Beyond Superficial Social Media Influence
Summary
In this episode, Angie and John discuss the concept of 'influencers' and the superficial image it often conveys. They critique the conventional idea of influencers as people with a large social media following but little substance.
They emphasize that true influence should reflect genuine professional expertise and personal authenticity.
The conversation touches on the importance of creating an intentional visual and personal brand that resonates with one’s audience, the balance between presenting a polished image and being relatable, and the relevance of sharing personal stories to connect with audiences.
They also explore the evolving nature of influence in the digital age and offer insights on achieving credibility and genuine connection in the world of social media and professional coaching.
Chapters
00:00 Introduction: What Does It Mean to Be an Influencer?
00:13 Reclaiming the Word 'Influencer'
01:22 The Superficial Side of Social Media
02:42 Personal Stories and Authenticity
03:48 The Importance of Visual Branding
06:57 Balancing Professionalism and Authenticity
18:01 Sharing Stories to Connect
21:09 Conclusion and Viewer Engagement
Want to contact the show? You can leave us a voicemail. It's free to do and we might feature you on our next episode. All you need to do is go to https://speakpipe.com/thecoachingclinicpodcast and leave us a message.
You can send us a video or voice message on LinkedIn:
John's LinkedIn Profile or go to PresentInfluence.com for coaching enquiries with John
2023 Present Influence Productions The Coaching Clinic 51
Transcript
Angie,
2
:Angie: John?
3
:John: are you an influencer?
4
:Angie: Ha.
5
:At home I am.
6
:You can just ask my dogs.
7
:John: I mean more online
like social media influencer,
8
:Angie: Oh no.
9
:Not until I get my teeth whitened.
10
:A spray tan.
11
:Getting those photos ready.
12
:John: Angie, I think it's time we
reclaimed the word influencer and talk
13
:about what it really means to have
online influence and how to do it.
14
:Angie: I like where this is going.
15
:Let's open up the coaching clinic.
16
:John: The doors are open.
17
:And Angie, we're talking about
influence and influencers and we
18
:probably have this concept in our
minds now of what an influencer is.
19
:What do you think of when
you hear the word influencer?
20
:I.
21
:Angie: It's so funny 'cause I
know we talked about this and
22
:I feel how do I explain this?
23
:I'm not articulating well yet, but I feel
like the influencer is that person who
24
:really just, that's what they're doing.
25
:They're focusing on the influencer
part of it without as much I feel
26
:like substance to a specific cause.
27
:It's quick hits.
28
:It's less to me.
29
:And I am going to get, we're
gonna get hate mail over this.
30
:John: I feel you may be hitting on
the head some of my thoughts about
31
:this as well, that I probably think
more when I hit the word influencer
32
:of the more superficial side of
social media, which is all about
33
:image and not really about substance.
34
:And so it is like having those perfect
white teeth and perfect hair and big
35
:smiles and perfect life and all of that.
36
:And I think that word has been, influencer
has been associated with that for so long.
37
:I hope that's starting to change and
I certainly would want to be a part of
38
:trying to reclaim the word influencer to
mean something that it should, because
39
:at the moment all it really means is
someone who has a big online following.
40
:Really, that's essentially it.
41
:They have a lot of followers on social
media that makes them an influencer
42
:because they have potentially
influence over the audiences that
43
:are following them on social media.
44
:Angie: Yeah.
45
:I think the word I was fey
for earlier was superficial.
46
:And listen, and that's not to stay, right?
47
:So we're not right John, we're not
here to bash that, that space, because
48
:John: look, hot people can stay hot.
49
:That's fine.
50
:We'll let them, we'll give them that.
51
:If you're hot and you're getting
followers because of that, you carry on.
52
:Angie: Absolutely.
53
:I mean there's definitely some merits to
that if that's the space that you're in.
54
:For example I love to cook
and I have been thinking about
55
:doing, like cooking with Angie.
56
:I go by Coach Angie.
57
:I.
58
:Andrew speaks and all the
things, but I love to cook.
59
:My husband is constantly chasing me
around with a phone in the kitchen
60
:and he's look at all these people.
61
:You make better meatballs than them.
62
:So that would be me being an
influencer, maybe in the cooking space.
63
:But I feel like, in the coaching,
in the speaking space, that is
64
:not at all how I want to be.
65
:Received or perceived, honestly.
66
:I wanted to have a little
more guts to it than that.
67
:John: I would tune into watching making
meatballs, but maybe that's 'cause I know
68
:you and I would certainly like to know
what goes into Angie's Meatballs, but I.
69
:it comes to being an influencer online I
don't think the whole Instagram influencer
70
:thing is quite as big as it was.
71
:And certainly hot people are always
gonna get followed because they're hot.
72
:They're always gonna have people who
are checking 'em out, whatever else.
73
:Just because they're attractive or they're
fun or whatever else, and that's fine.
74
:It's like there's a place for that.
75
:There really is, but it shouldn't tarnish
what is going on in terms of professional
76
:influence or having more stuff going on
and having a bit more substance to what
77
:you do, and having something to say and
the social media platforms can really be
78
:that, that one of the things that I found
is if you, but look, let me ask you this.
79
:Would you want people to be following
you just 'cause you're hot and sexy?
80
:I.
81
:Angie: Hey.
82
:John: Would you personally want
that to be the only reason really
83
:that people are following you?
84
:Angie: Absolutely not
because it has no sustenance.
85
:Then I'm only as good as
the last greatest thing.
86
:I did.
87
:That's my positioning on that.
88
:I want there to be real value, but
again, I think that's why I don't
89
:look at myself as an influencer.
90
:And it was very difficult.
91
:I struggled with, even everybody's
been telling you for years, you
92
:need to start making videos.
93
:Years ago, first speaking gig I
ever did, they asked for my, do
94
:you have any videos on YouTube?
95
:And I was like, no.
96
:I just didn't I didn't, I felt
maybe what a lot of people feel
97
:that there had to be the image that
came before the crux of what I was
98
:doing instead of building the image.
99
:I definitely did not.
100
:Look at it the way most
people do nowadays.
101
:Now it's like commonplace.
102
:Back then I resisted it.
103
:I wanted nothing to do with
social media in that way.
104
:Nothing.
105
:Who knew?
106
:John: However I would not want the
only reason for people to follow
107
:me online to be because I'm hot and
sexy, even though I am obviously,
108
:Angie: You are so sexy.
109
:If you could see John's hair today.
110
:John: It.
111
:My, I'm quite happy with
my hair this week for once.
112
:But yeah, I wouldn't want it to be the
only reason that people are following me.
113
:But just realistically there is
like this inherent bias towards
114
:people who are more attractive and
we get even more conditioned toward
115
:that with TV and things like that.
116
:So we do have to compete with that.
117
:But I think one of the ways we do that.
118
:And it is perhaps on the more superficial
level is by looking the part we should
119
:look like we reflect who we want to be.
120
:The brands that we have, we need to
pretty much look like, alright, you
121
:know what you're talking about it's all
part of creating, and I'm not gonna say
122
:this as an illusion, but creating this
perception of competence and of being.
123
:Now if you go one, one of the reasons
why when you go to the opticians or
124
:maybe your beauty salon a lot of them
will be wearing white coats, it's
125
:not 'cause they're medical doctors
or they need to be white coats.
126
:No to it's because it gives you this
sense of that they are qualified
127
:and they know what they're doing.
128
:It's a uniform and it's there for you.
129
:So they look the part that's right.
130
:I'm not asking, wouldn't
ask them to change it.
131
:They look the part.
132
:We need to look the part as well.
133
:So it is an important element of your
influence to, to look like you should
134
:look for what you want to do or to
look like your audience would want you
135
:to look and still stay true to your
own style as much as you can as well.
136
:Angie: I think that the, yes,
and I feel like, there's been a
137
:transition, there's been a growth.
138
:That space and whether we like them or
not, like obviously the bigger names of
139
:coaching and speaking, the Tonys, the
Mels, all those people, they're getting
140
:into that posting and posting and posting.
141
:They didn't necessarily create it,
but they definitely hopped onto it.
142
:So I feel like there's a little
gray area for the people who
143
:aren't the Tonys and the Mels
yet, because there's this want to.
144
:I don't know how to pronounce his name.
145
:I think his last name is ach.
146
:Did you ever see him on
147
:John: yeah, Gary Vaynerchuk.
148
:Angie: Call him
149
:John: He often, yeah, most
people shorten it to Gary V.
150
:So I think we're good with that.
151
:Angie: So here's the thing.
152
:I'm like kicking myself in the butt
saying I could have Gary V all day long.
153
:'cause he's huge, whether
you like him or not.
154
:Because he's very, we know, right?
155
:He's very potty mouth.
156
:He just says it the way it is and
I'm thinking, I'm looking at him
157
:saying to myself, I could do that.
158
:'cause he does, he still
does have great messaging.
159
:But he just says it in such
a way that's relatable.
160
:And obviously his target audience
is a very specific group.
161
:And I'm thinking, I could have potty
mouth, I could have combined my
162
:potty mouth with my knowledge and
experience and been that person.
163
:Aha.
164
:But the joke is, joy,
did I really want that?
165
:And the answer was no.
166
:That was my answer.
167
:It was like, I don't want to do that.
168
:What do I want to be?
169
:Image wise, as a coach and a speaker,
and I don't know about you, let me
170
:ask you, so do you feel like for
you, the image the influencer needs
171
:to be more polished, that type of a,
172
:John: I ideally.
173
:Really and I'll tell you what,
I don't necessarily think that
174
:it has to start off that way.
175
:I think we can and should start
imperfectly and build from there.
176
:And it's okay for your audience
to see growth and transformation
177
:over that time as well as you
develop and figure things out.
178
:If you are aiming to have a professional,
respected brand that people can trust,
179
:I think there is an element to which
you need to at least be able to settle
180
:people's minds a bit about, oh you do
actually make some effort to at least look
181
:and seem like the part that you should do.
182
:And again, this isn't
trying to fool anyone.
183
:It's all about creating the feel
that feels right for you and for your
184
:audience and for what you're doing.
185
:The level of professionality that you
want to have if I wanted to purely
186
:talk to business executives, I probably
would have a little bit less of music
187
:books and Star Wars models behind me.
188
:And a bit more of a professional not
austere necessarily, but a bit more
189
:classical background of, okay, let's
get rid of the fun stuff a bit more.
190
:And now we, maybe we could
have a splash of that, but.
191
:Make it much more professional looking.
192
:So it's gonna look more like a corporate
environment, because that's really what
193
:they're expecting to see, and that's
where they're gonna see later, like,
194
:all right, I'm getting a corporate sense
from you and getting that image as well.
195
:So I do think the image stuff
is important to some degree.
196
:Your visual brand does matter.
197
:And if you look.
198
:A bit crappy on video.
199
:People are gonna judge that you
haven't really made much of an
200
:effort, or maybe you're new to this.
201
:Or I think more and more if you're putting
out content on YouTube and you don't look
202
:like you have a professional setup, people
are less likely to want to watch you.
203
:I say it's a bit like in a restaurant,
like if your food could come out looking
204
:like crap and taste amazing, but if it
comes out and looks like crap, you're
205
:probably not gonna want to eat it because
that's all part of the image and the
206
:experience, so we, with our eyes to
some degree, your food could come out
207
:and look amazing and tastes like crap.
208
:These things can happen, but you're more
likely to have a better experience if
209
:your food looks good and tastes good.
210
:Angie: Yeah, I have some challenge
on that and it's not that I disagree
211
:because I love the analogy of how
your food is plated but I think what
212
:I realized is that I worked very
hard to create a specific image.
213
:And what I found in working with
specific people, is that right?
214
:'cause my audience is professional, right?
215
:The executive.
216
:And I think a lot of people are a little
surprised to hear that because when you
217
:and I are talking, I'm not like sitting
here that this polish, I just am who I am.
218
:And when I get on with some of these
people, like on video and stuff.
219
:They're living just the way that they are.
220
:So I would be like looking, if I
was the executive that you were
221
:looking to coach or speak with,
I'd be like, that is so cool.
222
:Look at this guy with
all his Star Wars things.
223
:Because it shows the little
bit of the human side.
224
:So again, this is not to say what John
is saying is wrong 'cause it's not,
225
:but I think it's along the lines of
kind of still being who you are and.
226
:Injecting that into the
image as well, because
227
:John: But this is a little different
when we're talking about working
228
:one-to-one with clients though
to, when you're publishing stuff
229
:onto social media platforms.
230
:And sometimes when I'm working one-to-one
with clients, I've done that from coffee
231
:bars, I've done that from all sorts of
places when I've needed to, and it doesn't
232
:really matter that much, but when you
are looking to be an authority online, I
233
:think how you come across visually does
matter much as that this guy, this podcast
234
:is made primarily an audio podcast.
235
:And so it needs to sound reasonably
good as well because if the audio sucks.
236
:People aren't gonna want to listen.
237
:Angie: Oh, absolutely.
238
:John: And if the show's not edited and we
don't have a proper beginning of music and
239
:stuff like that, these are all things that
add those credibility elements to what we
240
:do and create influence by giving us that.
241
:Oh these guys know what they're
doing actually to some degree.
242
:It is important and it's different when
we're talking about what you're gonna
243
:potentially put out to the world, to what
you may put out on a one-to-one call or
244
:a group coaching program where you are
interacting more personally with people
245
:in those elements and there's a lot more
leeway and there're focused more on you.
246
:But even then, if you have stuff in your
environment, I feel like this is a little
247
:Ted talk now, but if you have stuff in
your environment that helps to solidify
248
:or secure that image or that sense of
who you are, where you may want things
249
:that, my background is intentional.
250
:It does represent stuff that I
genuinely have interest in, and it's
251
:designed in my head to be fun, to
show creativity and to show learning.
252
:So there's books, there's models,
there's pictures, there's a keyboard
253
:there with music book on it.
254
:Those are the things that I want
people to associate with me because
255
:they are things that are about me.
256
:So having those in my environment gives
that tells you that unconsciously,
257
:if you're seeing me on video
258
:Angie: I know it's very intentional
because this is not your home office.
259
:This is an office that you
leave your home to go to.
260
:John: Yeah.
261
:Angie: Oh, this is just the room in
John's house and this is where he stores
262
:his, personal stuff, like your office.
263
:And the first time we got on video, I
was like, oh my gosh, you like Star Wars?
264
:Remember it started this
whole conversation about.
265
:Doctor who and all the things.
266
:John: Yeah.
267
:Angie: Insight as to
really just who you are.
268
:And that's what I was thinking as I
was saying what I was saying earlier.
269
:So your office is definitely,
it's very intentional.
270
:It's not just some extra room in
your house where you're just throwing
271
:your things that don't fit any place
else that you know, your spouse
272
:won't let you keep out in the open.
273
:This is your space.
274
:So I do agree you should,
here's the thing I.
275
:I think that we need to be
intentional about what the image
276
:is that we want to portray.
277
:I do think so.
278
:To some degree.
279
:It's not a fake it thing, it's
just you need to be, who's your
280
:audience and how are you showing up?
281
:Because honestly, if I'm gonna talk
to teenagers, for example, and that's
282
:my space, that's my audience, or
I'm gonna be coaching with them,
283
:I'm not showing up in the suit.
284
:I have them, but that they're gonna
look at me and go, oh my goodness.
285
:Look at her.
286
:I'm in like jeans and sneakers
and I'm like, Hey guys.
287
:And I'm speaking a bit differently.
288
:So to your point than if I'm speaking
to the executives, I'm certainly, my
289
:hair's not in a ponytail and I'm not
wearing like a jean jacket or something.
290
:I'm gonna change that bit.
291
:You have to be intentional about it.
292
:But I think.
293
:Really get caught up like that.
294
:They, that they look at influence and
influencer, like they're interchangeable.
295
:That they mean the same thing.
296
:John: I don't know.
297
:I don't know, to be honest with you.
298
:I do think most people probably
understand that influence and
299
:influencer are not the same thing.
300
:I.
301
:Dictionary wise, anyone who
exerts influencers an influencer.
302
:So technic
303
:Angie: Did you just say dictionary?
304
:John: Yeah.
305
:Just official definition would be anyone
who has influence and the way we use
306
:the language is a little different.
307
:So the association we tend to have
with influencer is someone who has
308
:a big social media following and
probably posts lots of photographs of
309
:delicious meals and beautiful families
and sexy bodies and whatever else.
310
:I do think that is somewhat
changing, or at least I hope it is.
311
:I can only really say from my perspective
that I feel like that is changing somewhat
312
:because I see far less of what people
generally associate as the sort of fake
313
:lifestyle gurus who look like they have
this perfect body and image and all
314
:that, and you know that can't be real.
315
:Like you're, you are just
seeing edited highlights.
316
:But it is alright, this is a curated
image curated lifestyle, and we do need
317
:to somewhat curate for ourselves as
well to what we put out to the world.
318
:Because being authentic doesn't
mean to say that I need to turn the
319
:camera and show you a sink full of
dirty dishes or something like that.
320
:Not that there is
321
:Angie: don't wanna see me when I
wake up in the morning for sure
322
:John has, but the rest of you don't.
323
:John: The, that's the thing is like with
authenticity needs to be to a degree you
324
:need to stay true to who you are, but we
don't need to lay ourselves bare for the
325
:audience and reveal all of our secrets.
326
:We do still need to curate and
decide what is okay or cool to share.
327
:With people and what isn't.
328
:And it's it's a really difficult thing.
329
:'cause some people think that authenticity
just means you just, you or, but we are
330
:all different in different situations.
331
:Angie: Sure.
332
:John: I think we do need to decide
how we want to be showing up and
333
:how we want to be perceived online.
334
:It's all branding but to have influence
with that it's important that we look
335
:right, that as best we can, we sound
right and that we are sharing good content
336
:and a little bit of ourselves that we
share some stuff about us personally.
337
:I think you know who
Russell Brunson is, right?
338
:Have you heard of Russell Brunson?
339
:Yeah.
340
:The ClickFunnels guy.
341
:I'm not a ClickFunnels fan or cult
member some people call it, but his
342
:books which I think he has at least
three, and they're all online secrets or
343
:social media secrets, really good books
on how to build up your brand and how
344
:to share socially and set yourself up as
a person of influence in your industry.
345
:And that sharing a lot of professional
knowledge and insight and sharing
346
:some personal elements of you as
well, so that people can connect with
347
:you as a human being, not just as
an object or a professional thing.
348
:It's like you have a
bit more reality to you.
349
:More and more people are sharing stories.
350
:Have you noticed this, that more and more
people are sharing stories online these
351
:days and I think something we should all
probably do more of because stories are
352
:a great way to connect with each other
and for people to feel more personal
353
:stories about you, about your family,
354
:not the LinkedIn BS
stuff about oh, my child.
355
:My child came and said this to me the
other day, and you know that's either
356
:been made up or really because they're
trying to make some sort of point on
357
:LinkedIn and yeah, not that, but real
stuff that happens to you in your life
358
:that can be shared and maybe gives
you an insight because very often.
359
:The biggest realizations or insights we
have come in the mundane areas of our
360
:lives, and we can share those stories.
361
:Angie: Oh my gosh.
362
:I would say most of the ideas in my
personal content for speaking or quote
363
:has come from a real life experience
of my own or even with a client and
364
:I'm like, oh, let me write that down.
365
:Or even some of our ideas here.
366
:It happens very naturally and
organically and we're like, Hey,
367
:we should be talking about that.
368
:So that's, I think where the authenticity
piece comes in at, that everything
369
:isn't planned and structured.
370
:I'm gonna be honest with
you, I'm a Disney fan.
371
:I don't wanna take the tour behind.
372
:I don't wanna go behind the scenes
and see the inner workings because
373
:I like living in the world, right?
374
:I like living in the
image because I like it.
375
:I don't wanna change
how I feel about that.
376
:So there's only so far I want to go.
377
:And on the flip side of that.
378
:There's only so much that I want to share.
379
:I will be authentic.
380
:But again, nobody needs to see
ri when she first wakes up in the
381
:morning and her hair is everywhere.
382
:And I'm telling everybody about things
that are not really relevant unless there
383
:is a specific this is what I'm doing.
384
:No, you don't wanna see, oh, Angie's
cleaning her toilet bowl today.
385
:Nobody wants to see that in the
coaching and speaking world.
386
:Not really.
387
:John: There are elements of your
life that people would just feel,
388
:why are you telling me this?
389
:Why is this relevant in
any way, shape, or form?
390
:Or, it doesn't really tell me anything
about you, or it doesn't tell me anything
391
:I want to hear or know about you.
392
:And that stuff is better curated out.
393
:And this is kinda what
we're talking about.
394
:Get rid of the fluff and the nonsense and
stuff that nobody is gonna care about.
395
:And when you are sharing personal
stuff, share it to connect with people.
396
:And when you're sharing
professional stuff, again, share
397
:that to connect, but share it to.
398
:Educate, entertain and all
those good things as well.
399
:Angie: Do you have a question
for the coaching clinic?
400
:John: Reach out on LinkedIn to
connect with Angie and John.
401
:Angie: Leave us a voicemail
or video message and we will
402
:feature you on the show.
403
:John: You can also leave up
to 92nd voicemail for free
404
:on www.speakpipe.com/the
405
:Coaching Clinic podcast.
406
:Angie: We'd love to hear from you.
407
:John: See you next time.
408
:Angie: Bye for now.